cbc.ca (© Copyright: (C) Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, http://www.cbc.ca/aboutcbc/discover/termsofuse.html#Rss)
Updated: Fri, 27 Sep 2013 23:15:41 GMT | By CBC News, cbc.ca

Autistic girl refused treatment by B.C. dentist



Sophia Filiatrault, 12, and her mother, Paulette Weismiller. CBC

Sophia Filiatrault, 12, and her mother, Paulette Weismiller. CBC

The parents of a girl with autism have filed a human rights complaint against a Chilliwack, B.C., dentist after they were told not to return to the clinic.

Sophia Filiatrault, 12, was considered untreatable by the dental office because she could not sit still and refused to open her mouth.

Paulette Weismiller, Sophia’s mother, said she originally felt lucky to find Dr. Yoon Jai Choi, whose practice and staff specialize in high anxiety cases. 

But when she returned for follow-up visits, there was a problem.

"Sophia was nervous being in there, because she was in pain and she doesn't like anyone in her mouth, anyways,” Weismiller said.

An employee of the clinic, "Weismiller recalled. 

After this visit ended badly, the dental office wrote a note saying the girl should not be booked again.

The College of Dental Surgeons of B.C. says Choi has a right to dismiss a patient.

"In order for there to be a good clinical relationship, there has to be a good relationship between the patient and the dentist,” said Jerome Marburg, registrar at the college.

“And sometimes, through no fault of either parties, that relationship cannot be established."

Autism on the rise

"Everyone has to be more aware of children with autism,” said Katy Harandi, spokeswoman for the Canucks Autism Network, noting that one in 88 children now have the illness. 

"It's growing very fast. As a doctor or dentist, you will be seeing more cases of children with autism in your office."

Choi declined an on-camera interview, but told CBC News he has other patients with autism whom he’s had no problems treating. He says a severe case like Sophia’s would be better treated either with sedation or by a specialist.

But Sophia's father says that's unreasonable.

"We don't want Sophia to go unconscious every six months for a cleaning for the rest of her life,” said Bernard Filiatrault. “We want her to get used to going to a dentist and getting her teeth cleaned."

The BC Human Rights Tribunal is looking into the complaint. A decision on whether to go to a hearing has not yet been made.

more video